Feed on Posts or Comments 03 June 2023

Media newlight on 26 Mar 2008 08:18 pm

Tibet and beyond

Among many commentaries about what happened in Tibet and what would happen at Beijing Olympics, some groups advocate either boycotting Beijing Olympics altogether or at least the opening ceremony, or encouraging athletics openly demonstrate during the Games, wearing a Free Tibet t-shirt while competing for example. To see what kind of reaction their proposed action may get, one can do worse than checking the response from the eighty thousand or so Chinese students in the UK. Although most of them won’t hesitate to criticise Chinese government’s handling of events, such as a blind ban of the foreign media, many believe the western media are equally biased and untrustworthy. On the overseas Chinese discussion boards, there have been heated debate, mainly among overseas Chinese students themselves, about whether Tibetan are treated well enough, and how strained the relationship between Tibetan and Han-Chinese is, however most of the participants see Tibet as an integral part of China, many also accuse western media as being one-sided or even fabricating in reporting the violence in Tibet. A seven minute video posted onto YouTube (has been viewed near two million times) reflects the feeling shared by many Chinese students.

A new website, anti-cnn.com, has been set up to expose the western media outlets like CNN, German N-TV, as well as BBC and The Times of “manipulation of evidence” and “biased reporting”. It looks many quite a few western news organisations, in the immediate aftermath of Lhasa riot, used the pictures of Indian and Nepalese police taking away demonstrators in their reports as the evidence of “Chinese army used brutal force to crack down protest”. One screenshot of BBC News website shows a picture of Chinese soldiers wearing medic arm band standing behind an ambulance with the caption of “a heavy military presence in Lhasa”. A YouTube video then shows a slideshow compilation of the materials.

In the UK, an open letter to the Prime Minister Gordon Brown has been circulated among Chinese students in which the author points out the biased reporting by western media and asks Gordon Brown “not to meet Dalai Lama” when he comes to the UK in May. After the disruption of Olympic flame-lighting ceremony and torch relay in Greece, there are also calls on the message boards to “support the Olympic torch” when it tours through the UK.

Those are highly-educated, well-informed, worldly young generation of Chinese. If even they are suspicious of west’s fairness and motivation, one can imagine the reaction from Chinese public if the west try to boycott or demonstrate publicly during Beijing Olympic to “send a message”. For many Chinese, those actions will be seen as unjust and unfair, a bullying tactics. Moreover, it underlines the mistrust and snobbery towards China among some members of the western activists who see Olympics as a reward given to China for the good behavior, which can be taken away at any time, solely on westerns’ judgment. The freedom and fairness of western media used to be what Chinese people look up to, however, in the recent years, in particularly among the younger generations, west’s sometimes automatic self-entitlement to the moral high ground when dealing with affairs related to China has been seriously questioned.

For many years in the last century, China lived in a sometimes forced, sometimes self-imposed ideological and economical isolation. Now with the rapid growth of economical power, China starts to feel the need to be loved and respected by the international community. What the west can do is to find an effective way to show China how to behave responsibly to order to gain respect and influence. If the western media and pressure groups fall into the old habit of bashing China with the morality stick (while the economy stick is no longer available) every time, it won’t help to convince the Chinese authority to leave their old habit of the siege mentality behind and learn to live under the international spotlight. The problem China has to resolve in Tibet, is a common issue faced by many countries, that is how to deal with the grievance of ethnic minorities and their fear of lose of cultural identity. The west can certainly share some lessons with China, but if they simply want to teach China a lesson, I’m afraid the message won’t be well received.

12 Responses to “Tibet and beyond”

  1. on 27 Mar 2008 at 11:46 1.imacover said …

    Hi, newlight

    This is imacover on LKCN. Your article is very well written. Could I ask for your permission to redistribute it in a PDF file?

    Many thanks,

  2. on 27 Mar 2008 at 17:44 2.newlight said …

    Yes as long as the text are not altered without permission.

  3. on 04 Apr 2008 at 03:44 3.LinkChinese UK News » Opinion: Tibet and beyond said …

    [...] From Pin Lu on WaterInk.net [...]

  4. on 09 Apr 2008 at 19:18 4.Water Ink » Flame it up said …

    [...] protesters wanted to ‘embarrass China into acceptance’, they are most likely to find their efforts totally counter-productive. Not only this forces China into a stand off confrontation, but also galvanises Chinese people into [...]

  5. on 10 Apr 2008 at 07:26 5.LinkChinese UK News » Opinion: Flame it up said …

    [...] protesters wanted to ‘embarrass China into submission’, they are most likely to find their efforts totally counter-productive. Not only this forces China into a stand off confrontation, but also galvanises Chinese people into [...]

  6. on 04 Apr 2010 at 14:31 6.Goji Berry Supplement said …

    I just wanted to extend my gratitude very much for this indepth site. I’ve already favorited your site, when I have more free time I am going to have to do some extensive surfing of your webpage. Well back to searching for goji berry supplements

  7. on 08 Mar 2023 at 19:26 7.Gyloavy said …

    September 2010 buy cialis canada pharmacy

  8. on 10 Mar 2023 at 17:09 8.Mitogma said …

    injection and for axolotl transgenesis using I SceI meganuclease and the mini Tol2 transposon system buy generic cialis online

  9. on 01 Apr 2023 at 19:57 9.louis vuitton outlet online said …

    I received my bag yesterday along with They look and feel great such I’m so pleased with my purchase you ultimately choose Thank you for the bag and it was a pleasure doing business with you guys.
    louis vuitton outlet online https://www.louisvuittonsoutlet.com/

  10. on 05 Apr 2023 at 15:44 10.Andrewgem said …

    You said this well.
    research paper to buy help on writing a research paper proposal writer need to buy a research paper

  11. on 03 May 2023 at 23:23 11.bowilligh said …

    Clinical Significance of Combined Detection of Serum Hcy, HE4 and SA Levels in Patients with Ovarian Cancer buying cialis generic 8 Chest CT showed multiple nodules, cavities, and pleural effusion 4 Left hip joint nocardiosis Nocardia brasiliensis Left hip pain, weight loss 7

  12. on 06 May 2023 at 03:22 12.Glyclehal said …

    Other findings in adenomyosis include small myometrial cysts representing dilated cystic glands and echogenic nodules and or linear striations extending from the endometrium into the myometrium representing ectopic endometrial tissue finasteride 1 mg online pharmacy Does an orgasm lower bp

Trackback This Post | Subscribe to the comments through RSS Feed

Leave a Reply